Tuesday, August 9, 2022



Twitter-India war: Letter game, arrest threats but no action

New Delhi, Feb 11, 2021-
The tussle between Twitter and the Union government reached its zenith on Thursday with a firebrand speech in the Rajya Sabha by IT Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad cautioning the micro-blogging platform to pay heed to the law of the land — raising the pitch beyond issuing notices and social media posts.

The war of words has been going on for over 10-15 days and we have seen a letter trail, social media outcries (latest example being Koo) and an “unusual” Twitter blog post but no stern action has been taken by the government to date.

Legal experts argue that if the government can ban several Chinese apps including giants like TikTok and PUBG, why can’t they act on US-based tech giants, and the government does not even need a data privacy law like the EU GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) to find a way to penalise Twitter if they have strong reasons that the company has repeatedly failed to comply with its directions.

Twitter says it cannot suspend of block nearly 1,435 accounts specified by the government as it “does not believe that the actions it has been directed to take by the IT Ministry are consistent with the Indian law and violates fundamental right to free expression”.

Prasad replied in Rajya Sabha: “There is freedom of speech but Article 19A says that this is subject to reasonable restrictions”.

According to Virag Gupta, the lawyer of former RSS ideologue K.N. Govindacharya, who is arguing the social media Designated Officers’ matter before the Delhi High Court, said that the IT Ministry can take action as per their “will power”.

“They have banned Chinese apps under the existing legal jurisprudence so that can take down the social media platforms too,” Gupta told.

‘Buy why only Twitter? Why not WhatsApp that was embroiled in the Pegasus spyware controversy and Facebook that let Cambridge Analytica happen that compromised millions of Indians’ data too?” he asked.

The government can initiate action for suspension or blocking of intermediary apps or websites if they fail to comply with its directions.

“As per Section 69A (3), there is provision of seven years’ imprisonment and fine,” Gupta reiterated.

In case Twitter fails to comply with the government directions, the latter has the powers to resort to penal consequences.

“In that direction, appropriate FIRs can be registered against intermediaries and service providers and their top management can also be made liable for the said contravention under Section 85 of the Information Technology Act, 2000,” said Pavan Duggal, one of the country’s top cyber law experts.

The government can exercise its power under the Section 69(A)(1).

In case, any service provider or intermediary fails to comply with the provisions of the same, then there are penal consequences prescribed under Section 69A(3). Non-compliance with directions for blocking is a non-bailable serious offence punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine.

However, till today, we haven’t seen any reported conviction under Section 69(A)(3) of the Information Technology Act, 2000 in the public domain.

It is to be seen which direction the whole Twitter-India saga will go from here on, in the absence of a strong data protection law. (Agency)

Action will be taken if Twitter, Facebook platforms are misused: Govt

- Advertisement -

Yes Punjab - TOP STORIES

Punjab News

Sikh News

Transfers, Postings, Promotions

- Advertisement -spot_img

Stay Connected






Need for speed: The 5G promise, its enablers and roadblocks – by T.V. Ramachandran

The US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) recently proposed revising the definition of broadband to a minimum download speed of 100 mbps, and uploads at...

Civil services have to improve for better governance – by DC Pathak

There is a widely shared view that the All India Services, which provided the 'steel frame' of governance in a democratic India, granting Constitutional...

Will Pak Army Chief Bajwa or his successor reconcile ties with India? – by Rana Banerji

New Delhi, Aug 2, 2022- On July 25, the Supreme Court's three Judge bench headed by Chief Justice Omar Ata Bandial controversially struck down...


Health & Fitness

Low vitamin D could be behind chronic inflammation

Sydney, Aug 8, 2022- Researchers have found a direct link between low levels of vitamin D and high levels of inflammation. The findings, led by a team from University of South Australia, provides an important biomarker to identify people at higher risk of or severity of chronic illnesses with an inflammatory component. Inflammation is an essential part of the body's healing...

Gadgets & Tech

error: Content is protected !!