New Delhi, October 8, 2026 (Yes Punjab News)
The Delhi High Court has directed initiation of criminal complaint proceedings against six CBI officers over an allegedly false statement made before a court regarding correspondence with the administrative ministry in connection with a proposed challenge to the discharge of an IRS officer in a disproportionate assets case.
Justice Madhu Jain passed the order while allowing a criminal appeal filed by Indian Revenue Service (IRS) officer Ashok Kumar Aggarwal against the decision of a Special Judge at Rouse Avenue Courts, who had declined to initiate proceedings under Section 340 of the CrPC against the concerned CBI officers.
The High Court directed the Special Judge to file a written complaint against Sushil Dewan, Vineet Vinayak, Amit Kumar, Raman Tyagi, Prem Kumar Gautam and Md. Azad for alleged offences under Section 191 read with Section 193 of the IPC and Section 209 IPC. The complaint is to be forwarded to the jurisdictional Magistrate within four weeks of receipt of the judgment.
The matter arose from the CBI’s prosecution of Aggarwal in a disproportionate assets case under the Prevention of Corruption Act. The prosecution was based on a sanction order dated November 26, 2002.
In January 2016, the Delhi High Court held the sanction invalid, following which the Special Judge discharged Aggarwal in March that year. The CBI subsequently considered challenging the decision before the Supreme Court. However, the Ministry of Law and Justice, in an opinion dated June 8, 2016, found that there appeared to be no reasonable ground to pursue the matter before a higher forum.
The opinion was communicated to the CBI through the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) on July 1, 2016. Aggarwal later sought the release of documents seized during the investigation.
In a reply filed on August 2, 2016, the CBI opposed the release of certain documents, stating that correspondence with the administrative ministry regarding further legal action was underway.
The Special Judge subsequently directed the CBI to clarify whether any appeal or revision had actually been filed or was pending. Aggarwal then moved an application under Section 340 CrPC, alleging that the August 2 statement was factually false because there was no correspondence with the administrative ministry at that stage and the CBI had already received the Law Ministry’s opinion against pursuing the case before a higher forum.
The High Court found that the CBI forwarded a proposal to the DoPT seeking reconsideration and further legal opinion only on August 8, 2016.
An additional reply filed by the CBI on August 9 stated that the agency had, in principle, decided to challenge the January 2016 judgment and that the proposal had been forwarded to the DoPT on August 8.
The High Court also examined successive drafts of the CBI’s earlier reply. It noted that an earlier draft expressly stated that the DoPT had rejected the CBI’s proposal to file a special leave petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court. That statement was subsequently deleted and replaced by a handwritten assertion that correspondence with the administrative ministry was underway.
“This concerned alteration changed the very factual position sought to be presented before the Court,” the High Court observed.
The court prima facie attributed the handwritten alteration to then CBI Head of Zone Vineet Vinayak and found that Sushil Dewan subsequently incorporated it into the final reply filed before the lower court.
The High Court also noted the involvement of Prem Kumar Gautam, Amit Kumar, Md. Azad and Raman Tyagi in preparing, vetting, processing and approving the reply.
Rejecting the CBI’s argument that the statement was merely an incorrect assertion rather than a false one, the High Court said an internal proposal awaiting approval could not be represented as correspondence already underway with the administrative ministry.
“The CBI was entitled to seek reconsideration, obtain another opinion and pursue such remedy as was available in law. However, its right to do so did not permit an internal proposal awaiting approval to be represented as a correspondence already underway with the Ministry,” the court said.
The court also rejected the argument that the subsequent August 9 reply had corrected the earlier statement. It noted that the later reply itself recorded that the proposal had been forwarded to the DoPT only on August 8.
The High Court further held that the absence of immediate prejudice to Aggarwal was not sufficient to rule out proceedings under Section 340 CrPC. It said the issue had to be examined in the context of the alleged offence’s impact on the administration of justice, rather than solely on the injury suffered by an individual litigant.
The court found the disputed statement material because it was used to justify continued retention of documents seized from Aggarwal and was capable of influencing the court’s decision on his application.
It held that the successive drafts, file notings and the officers’ respective involvement provided sufficient basis at this stage for allegations under the relevant IPC provisions.
“The threshold for directing a complaint under Section 340 of CrPC is therefore satisfied,” Justice Jain said, setting aside the Special Judge’s order and allowing Aggarwal’s application.
The High Court directed that the complaint be placed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate (Central), Tis Hazari Courts, where an earlier complaint against Sushil Dewan had been adjourned sine die.
The Magistrate was directed to proceed independently and ensure that parallel proceedings over the same allegations are not instituted.
The High Court also clarified that the competent court would independently determine the matter on the basis of the material before it and would not be influenced by the observations made in the judgment while deciding whether to proceed with the complaint.






























