Sunday, June 11, 2023



Right to protest fundamental right, but blocking road a concern: Supreme Court

- Advertisement -

New Delhi, Feb 17, 2020-

The Supreme Court on Monday said that right to protest is a fundamental right, but it is troubling to see protesters blocking the road at Shaheen Bagh, as it may set a bad precedent and spur action by other groups resulting in chaos. It also suggested that the Shaheen Bagh protest may be shifted to an alternate venue.

The top court appointed three interlocutors led by senior advocate Sanjay Hegde to talk to the Shaheen Bagh protesters regarding shifting the protest site and file a report in the court. Senior advocate Sadhna Ramachandran and former chief information commissioner Wajahat Habibullah are the other two interlocutors.

A bench headed by Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Justice K.M. Joseph, citing replication of protests involving blocking of public roads, said: “We are concerned as to what will happen if people start hitting the streets and blocking the roads while protesting.”

“Reasons must prevail upon them, as we are concerned about the blocking of the road,” it added.

The court suggested that Delhi Police may offer an alternative site to the protesters at Shaheen Bagh.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta contended before the court that the protesters can’t continue blocking roads on grounds of not getting an alternative site. To this, the court replied: “It is a fundamental right of the people to protest and people can protest.”

Mehta also contended that the message that every institution has been kneeling and praying to the protesters should not go out. Justice Joseph queried Mehta, “Then why did the Centre not take steps before this matter was brought before the top court. Why didn’t you act in the last 68 days?”

Mediators appointed to engage with Shaheen Bagh protesters on venue change

“For some reasons, you have not gone there. If nothing works out, we will leave it to you,” the bench told Mehta, who insisted that talks were held with welfare and market associations to lift restrictions on the road.

The observation from the apex court came while hearing the petitions filed by advocate Amit Sahni and BJP leader Nand Kishore Garg, seeking the removal of the protesters to end the road blockade.

The court said the protesters are aggrieved by a particular legislation (Citizenship Amendment Act). The challenge to this Act is pending before the top court.

“They may get favourable or unfavourable judgement… Our intrinsic concern is if everybody starts blocking roads or public areas, the question is where to protest. It should not happen on the streets. If another section occupies another road, that is the issue,” the court observed.

The top court said this may lead to chaos. “People may have strong views. The thing troubling us is blocking of the road,” said the court.

Mehta also submitted that protesters are using women and children at the protest site as a shield.

The court named Hegde to act as an interlocutor and asked him to seek assistance from former Habibullah and Ramachandran. Habibullah, along with Bhim Army Chief Chandrashekhar Azad, has filed an intervention application on the matter.

The court also observed that the authorities should favourably consider this aspect of the right to protest. The top court put the petitions seeking direction to Delhi Police to remove the road blockade at Shaheen Bagh for further consideration on February 24.  (Agency)

- Advertisement -

Yes Punjab - TOP STORIES

Punjab News

Sikh News

Transfers, Postings, Promotions


Stay Connected



Vivek Agnihotri’s ‘The Vaccine War’ will now release on Dussehra 2023

Mumbai, June 10, 2923- Filmmaker Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri has announced the beginning of the last schedule of his upcoming film 'The Vaccine War', based...

Pratik Sehajpal brings K-pop to India by collaborating with Aoora

Mumbai, June 10, 2023 (Yes Punjab News) The world of K-pop, known for its infectious beats, captivating choreography, and passionate fandoms, has been taking the...

After success at Cannes Film Festival, next in line is Sydney Film Festival for Sunny Leone’s Kennedy

Mumbai, June 10, 2023 (Yes Punjab News) Sunny Leone has been constantly upskilling herself every year with new releases across PAN-India. The next in line...

Bollywood celebrating its own destruction: Vivek Agnihotri on ‘Bloody Daddy’

Mumbai, June 9, 2023- Filmmaker Vivek Agnihotri, who has always been vocal about what's on his mind, has raised a question about Shahid Kapoor-starrer 'Bloody...

Alia Bhatt to portray Sita alongside Ranbir Kapoor as Ram in ‘Ramayana’

Mumbai, June 8, 2023- As 'Adipurush' gears up for its theatrical release bringing forth the tale of Ramayana, another film on the same theme is...

One seat booked in all theatres playing ‘Adipurush’ to honour Lord Hanuman

Mumbai, June 8, 2023- Filmmaker Om Raut, who is gearing up for the release of his upcoming film 'Adipurush', strongly believes that Lord Hanuman is...

Vijay Varma finds rumoured girlfriend Tamannaah’s latest pictures lit

Mumbai, June 7, 2023- Actress Tamannaah Bhatia shared a slew of pictures on social media every she looked every inch gorgeous. In the images, she...

Big B reveals why he greets fans bare feet: ‘My well wishers are my temple’

Mumbai, June 7, 2023- Megastar Amitabh Bachchan has opened up about why he greets his fans, who come outside his house religiously every Sunday,...




AI can avert Train Accidents – by Narvijay Yadav

Railway safety can be improved by using Artificial Intelligence (AI), which has the ability to rapidly process large amounts of data and information, resulting...

Unveiling India’s Struggle: Addressing Violence Against Women and Challenging Stereotypes – by Deepika Bhan

Almost 15 years ago, in a residential society in Noida in the National Capital Region, a Class VIII boy invited seven-eight girls, all up...

Combating Violence Against Women in India: A Call for Non-Political Action and Social Reform – by DC Pathak

The recent case of the brutal killing of a young girl in public by a 'jilted' boyfriend in Delhi who stabbed her with a...


Health & Fitness

Gadgets & Tech

error: Content is protected !!