Saturday, June 3, 2023



Prashant Bhushan cites 2018 press meet, Supreme Court hopes it’s last time judges go to press

- Advertisement -

New Delhi, Aug 31, 2020-

As advocate Prashant Bhushan, defending his expression of opinion through tweets, cited the press conference held by sitting apex court judges in January 2018, the Supreme Court on Monday dismissed his argument, saying it is settled that negative equality cannot be claimed as there is no such concept.

A bench comprising Justices Arun Mishra, B.R. Gavai and Krishna Murari said: “We hope it was the first and the last occasion that the judges have gone to press, and god gives wisdom to protect its dignity by an internal mechanism, particularly, when allegations made, if any, publicly cannot be met by sufferer judges. It would cause suffering to them till eternity.”

The apex court said Bhushan tried to justify the averments he made on the basis of the press conference held by the four senior-most judges of the court.

“Concept of equality before law… what is permissible, not as to what is impermissible. It is settled that negative equality cannot be claimed as there is no concept of negative equality,” said the bench.

The top court said truth can be a defence to the judges also, but they are bound by judicial norms, ethics, and code of conduct. “Similarly, the code of conduct for advocates is equally applicable to the lawyers also, being part of the system. The Rules of Professional Ethics formed by the Bar Council, though couched under statutory powers, are themselves not enough to prescribe or proscribe the nobility of profession in entirety. The nobility of profession encompasses, over and above, the Rules of Ethics,” observed the top court.

The bench said that fair criticism is based on the authentic and acceptable material permissible, but when criticism tends to create apprehension in the minds of the people regarding integrity, ability and fairness of the judge, it amounts to contempt. “Such criticism is not protected under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution,” said the bench.

Former Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, who was then a judge, and Justices Madan B. Lokur, Jasti Chelameswar and Kurian Joseph, held an unprecedented press conference on January 12, 2018, where they alleged that then Chief Justice Dipak Misra was violating conventions. All four judges have retired now.

The Supreme Court has imposed a token fine of Re 1 on Bhushan, convicted in a contempt case for tweets against the judiciary, which if he failed to deposit by September 15, will entail a penalty of 3 months in jail and the senior advocate will be barred from practicing law for three years.  (Agency)Yes Punjab Online Since 2012

Click here to Like us on Facebook

- Advertisement -

Yes Punjab - TOP STORIES

Punjab News

Sikh News

Transfers, Postings, Promotions


Stay Connected



Raftaar to ‘India’s Best Dancer 3’ contestant: ‘I can learn from you’

Mumbai, June 2, 2023- Rapper Raftaar, who is known for chartbusters like 'Bandook Meri Laila', 'Mantoiyat' and others, will be seen gracing the upcoming...

Ileana shares first glimpse of boyfriend since pregnancy announcement

Mumbai, June 2, 2023- Actress Ileana D'Cruz, who is all set to welcome her first bundle of joy, has shared a picture with a...

Bombay HC adjourns gangster’s plea to restrain Netflix’s ‘Scoop’

Mumbai, June 2, 2023- The Bombay High Court on Friday adjourned the hearing of a suit filed by jailed mafia don, Rajendra S. Nikhalje...

Kanye West ‘sued for assault, battery, negligence’ after row with paparazzi

Los Angeles, June 2, 2023- Rapper Kanye West is said to have been sued by a photographer for assault, battery and negligence following a...

‘Zara Hatke Zara Bachke’: Unique take on love, marriage & relationships – Movie Review

Director: Laxman Utekar. Cast: Vicky Kaushal, Sara Ali Khan, Inaamulhaq, Sushmita Mukherjee, Neeraj Sood, Rakesh Bedi and Sharib Hashmi. Rating: **** As a director, Laxman Utekar...

Bhojpuri singer Nisha Upadhyay injured in celebratory firing in Chapra

Patna, June 1, 2023- Bhojpuri singer Nisha Upadhyay sustained a gunshot injury in leg due to celebratory firing in an event in Bihar's Chapra,...

Singer Chinmayi Sripada Questions Tamil Nadu CM’s Silence on Sexual Assault Allegations

Chennai, June 1, 2023- While Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin extends his support to top wrestlers in their fight for justice against WFI...

Vikram Bhatt’s daughter Krishna Bhatt makes directorial debut with a horror film

Mumbai, June 1, 2023- Krishna Bhatt, the daughter of director-producer Vikram Bhatt, is set to make her debut with the upcoming horror film '1920...




Contiki Operating System can be the best stimulator for work on Low Power and Lossy Networks in IOT – by Anil Behal

There are several stages to analyze the Contiki operating system in LLNs, including choosing the correct metrics planning tests, and analysing the outcomes. These...

Rajouri and Kandi attacks: Can the failed Kashmir militancy bounce back with new tactics? – by Abhinav Pandya

New Delhi, May 15, 2023- Amidst disturbing developments, the good news is that the terror groups are finding it difficult to recruit the local...

Being ambivalent about faith-based terrorism is harmful – by DC Pathak

Amidst the continuing danger posed to national security by the Pak-instigated radicalisation and terrorism, many academicians and even some major think tanks are underplaying...


Health & Fitness

Gadgets & Tech

error: Content is protected !!