Thursday, July 29, 2021
400 July

Pension 1500 gif

Shaheed 50 lakh gif

Kisan Karza 5.64 lakh gif

Kisan 48 hours gif

Ashirwad 51000 gif

Sohna Markfed

Innocent Admission

Delhi Assembly has ‘inquisitorial role’, can seek info from Facebook: SC on Delhi Riots

- Advertisement -

New Delhi, July 8, 2021 –
The Supreme Court on Thursday said the Delhi Assembly’s Peace and Harmony Committee can seek information from Facebook and its officials in connection with their alleged role in Delhi riots.

A three-judge bench, headed by Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, said: “We cannot accept the plea that an Assembly must confine itself to the core function of legislation. This would be unreasonably restricting the role of an elected body.”

However, the bench also comprising Justices Dinesh Maheshwari and Hrishikesh Roy, clarified that the committee cannot go into issue of law and order and act as some kind of prosecuting agency.

The bench recognised that the “inquisitorial and recommendatory powers” of the committee can be utilised under the principle of better governance. Facebook’s representative would have a right to refuse to answer and this would not invite privilege proceedings, it added.

The bench emphasised that entities like Facebook have to remain accountable to those who entrust them with such power. “We cannot lose sight of the fact that it has simultaneously become a platform for disruptive messages, voices, and ideologies”, added the court, citing that election and voting processes, the very foundation of a democratic government, stand threatened by social media manipulation.

The top court termed as “premature” the apprehension of coercive action made by Facebook and its India Vice President and MD Ajit Mohan Mohan against the backdrop of summonses issued by the committee headed by AAP MLA Raghav Chadha.

“While we respect the right of the Committee to the extent that there exists an obligation on the petitioners to respond to the summonses, we cannot permit the proceedings to go on in a manner that encroaches upon the prohibited entries (public order, police and land).”

The top court upheld the committee’s counsel argument that the police cannot be the sole custodian of peace and harmony and that the expression itself has various connotations.

“Despite the state government being denuded of certain powers, it has to be noted that governance has many manifestations, and functions of the government can be realised in different ways. This is especially true in the present case where the situation was admittedly created through an intrinsically law and order issue,” said the bench.

It added the committee would be entitled to receive information and deliberate on the same to examine their bearing on peace and harmony without transgressing into any fields reserved for the Centre in the Seventh Schedule.

The court also said that the statement: “Facebook should be treated as a co-accused and investigated as a co-accused in Delhi riots investigation” and supplementary charge sheet should be filled considering Facebook as a co-accused, is completely outside the remit of the Committee and should not have been made.

In its 188-page judgement, the bench noted that it was pre-emptory to see a clash of privilege powers and certain fundamental rights free speech, silence, and privacy in the present matter.

The top court brushed aside Facebook’s assertion that it was merely intermediary, and added that India’s “unity in diversity”, cannot be disrupted at any cost or under any professed freedom by a giant like Facebook claiming ignorance or lack of any pivotal role.

The top court made these observations in a judgement where it dismissed the plea of Facebook and Mohan against the summonses issued to him by the Delhi Assembly’s Peace and Harmony committee for failing to appear before it as witness in connection with February 2020 Delhi riots.  (Agency)

Subscribe to YesPunjab Telegram Channel & receive important news updates

- Advertisement -

Yes Punjab - TOP STORIES

Punjab News

Sikh News

Transfers, Postings, Promotions

- Advertisement -spot_img

Stay Connected

20,369FansLike
111,905FollowersFollow

ENTERTAINMENT

National

GLOBAL

OPINION

Attack on Chinese in Pakistan

Who is behind the attack on Chinese in Pakistan – by Amjad Ayub Mirza

The deadly attack, carried out on July 15, on a coach carrying Chinese engineers to an under-construction tunnel site at the 4300 MW Dasu...
Coexistence

Coexistence, a unifying factor for Indians – by Asad Mirza

For most political parties, sociologists and psephologists what a common Indian on the street thinks matters most. It is an insight into a common...
Taliban Afghanistan

Taliban’s Next Stop: Kabul, Kashmir and Kerala – by Amjad Ayub Mirza

The speedy advance of the Taliban from northern Afghanistan to Kabul in the eastern section of the country could not have been achieved without...

SPORTS

Health & Fitness

Monsoon Hair Care

Monsoon Hair Care Tips

New Delhi, July 28, 2021- The monsoon season is much loved by all -- a welcome respite from the hot summer, cool showers bring out a rich, earthy scent and a gentle breeze blowing through the hair. Despite it being the season of love and romance -- the monsoon can be quite unhealthy for the hair and scalp. Just...

Gadgets & Tech

error: Content is protected !!